What college should i go to/ realistically where could i get in?

I have a 3.0 GPA from one of the best high schools in machusetts. I have taken 4 or 5 honors cles but no AP's. I received the National Merit Scholarship for outstanding PSAT scores, and my SAT score was a 2030. I want to be a psychology major. I'm also a 4 varsity sport athlete (soccer, ice hockey, lacrosse, and baseball. captain for lacrosse and hockey) I am in the Young Republican's Club and have participated in Relay for Life, and have other minor extra curriculars (jobs, etc)